The Atkins diet overhaul

Tuesday, March 23, 2010
The controversial Atkins diet, popular with super-fit celebs such as Jennifer Aniston, has been given a much-needed overhaul.

The latest Atkins diet book to hit the shelves, The New Atkins for a New You: The ultimate diet for shedding weight and feeling great, promotes a revised program called the "optimal protein diet", promising up to a 7kg weight loss in two weeks — and it's already made it on to the New York Times' bestsellers list.

The Atkins diet was developed initially in 1972 by Dr Robert Atkins, a US cardiologist. It was re-launched in 1992 and became a worldwide craze.

However, the diet was criticised for its extremely high levels of protein and saturated fats, and unwanted side effects such as lethargy, constipation and bad breath.

VIEW ARTICLE: 31 days to an A-list body

The new diet includes more vegetables and reduced amounts of animal fat and protein but still limits, especially in the beginning, nutrient-rich wholegrains, fruits and legumes. Atkins.com says the updates include:

  • a daily requirement for at least five servings of high-fibre "foundation vegetables";
  • easy ways to reduce or eliminate symptoms that may accompany the initial conversion to a low-carb eating approach;
  • advice on how to smooth the transition from one phase to the next, ensuring the gradual and natural adoption of healthy, permanent eating habits; and
  • a choice of two paths to take in phase four, lifetime maintenance.

"The research shows it's a healthy lifestyle and many more foods are a part of it," co-author Eric Westman, director of the Duke Lifestyle Medicine Clinic in Durham, North Carolina, told USA Today.

"It's also a therapeutic diet for people with diabetes, obesity, high triglycerides or high blood pressure. People who follow it have improvements."

VIEW GALLERY: Million-dollar bodies

Australian nutritionist Joanna McMillan Price spoke about the major changes to the diet on TODAY on Tuesday, but said there were still problems with it.

See the video above for the full interview.

"Basically, what they've done is they've recognised, first up, that not all carbs are bad for us," McMillan Price said.

And indeed, despite the popularity of low-carb diets, research has proven that carbs are not the enemy.

A study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine found obese people who followed either a low-carbohydrate or a low-fat diet for one year maintained a modest weight loss, around 2kg to 4kg, after three years. Those who followed a low-carb diet lost more weight initially but tended to regain more weight by the end of three years.

"This is certainly the right move in the direction for Atkins. I still think there are major flaws in the diet," McMillan Price said.

"They have at least started to limit the amount saturated fats and animal fats in the diet.

"I think this is an improvement but there are still some funny things. They still limit when you can start introducing nuts and seeds, when you can start having certain types of vegetables and I think that all gets incredibly complex."

See the video above for the full interview.

For health, beauty, celeb gossip and more, visit:

Your say: Would you try the new Atkins?

User reviews
Clint, sugars are carbohydrates. They are what is known as simple or mono carbohydrates because they contain only one type of sugar (be that fructose, glucose or sucrose). Other carbohydrates are complex carbs which contain different compounds, therefore have a lower glycaemic index. It takes the body longer to break them down, giving a slow burn, just like protein. Be that as it may, all carbohydrates are converted into glucose before being absorbed into the blood stream. The key to weight loss is to ensure that we eat like our ancestors did. Lots of veggies and some whole grains with a little fruit to add sweetness. Meat was an occasional thing in traditional societies and aboriginal diets (small a = all continents) are all like this. The Diabetes Revolution diet can be followed by vegetarians and vegans and I eat vegan 3 days a week with chicken, turkey or fish (twice a week) on other days. Today was gluten free veggie pizza night. Yay!
Definition of diet. 1. The usual food and drink of a person or animal. It's not something you follow for a set period of time, its the things you consume every single day. Everyone is on a diet, whether they like it or not. Has anyone ever heard of these things called "the Aust guide to healthy eating" and "aust dietary guidelines"?? they are there to assit people to be healthy and maintain a healthy weight with a good balanced diet. unlike all these fad books which are out there to, not to help, but to make money and nothing more! I find it disturbing that someone can believe that carbs=diabetes... (sally, perth), it shows we need to have better education around nutrition in Aust. Carbs are essential in our diet, especially considering that it is the only fuel source of our brain (hence the poor moods and cognitive function people experience when deprived of carbs). People just have to be smart about the type of carbs we consume. the more complex the better (think wholegrains).
5 years ago I went on the Atkins diet. I felt *** for the first 48 hours but after that I was full of energy. I was sleeping better and my cholesterol was down to the LOW end of the normal range. I lost 16kg in 12 weeks. After 10 years of yo-yo dieting trying milkshakes, soups and every other fad-diet that came out, this was THE ONLY ONE THAT DIDNT KEEP ME FEELING HUNGRY & DEPRIVED ALL THE TIME. I can recommend it and I have even surprised my GP. When I went to my doctor and he asked me how I lost so much weight in 3 months he was shocked and started telling me how bad the diet was, how much stress it puts on your body...on and on and on he went. The blood tests revealed just how much better everything in my body was performing. All I can say is, read the book, the WHOLE book and follow it exactly. Take all the vitamins and minerals it recommends, follow it exactly, I did and it has certainly paid off for me.
Wheat did not enter the human diet until just 10 thousand years ago, so we obviously do not require it in our diet.
I recently had my occupational health assessment and was diagnosed with diabetes. I can tell you now, a high carb diet does not give you diabetes or make you fat! Lots of sugar will. Fat isn't the only thing that will make you fat... sugar can also! Protein only helps with muscle growth and to carry insulin, which helps your body to process carbohydrates and sugars. Too much protein can block insulin secretion, which can, in turn, give you diabetes. I've been told that fruit and vegies are the best thing I can eat to bring down my blood sugar levels and keep them steady. Fruit and veg is full of carbs and NATURAL sugars, which is easiest for the body to digest and process. But the best thing to do to prevent diabetes and weight gain is exercise. This is what my own doc, and other doctors say as well. And since exercising on a regular basis, and eating more fruit and vegies, I've lost weight and my blood sugars are at a normal level.
I lost over 60kgs following weight watchers. I eat carbs everyday. If I want take out I get it - I just make better choices or if I indulge, then I make sure its a controlled indulgence and work it off. Today I ate - 2 weetbix with skim milk and a latte, a diet yoghurt, homemade banana bread, homemade moussaka and vegies and 10 rice crackers with 2 slices low fat cheese. i still have afternoon snacks and dinner to go - I'm having healthy nachos for dinner by the way. Why follow these restrictive diets? I don't understand the mentality. I'm in my healthy weight range and I got there by eating good, wholesome, healthy food. And I exercise 5 days a week. I love food (obviously - that's how I got so fat) but luckily I didn't have to give anything up to loose the weight. It really is that simple and I can do this for life.
I went on atkins years ago and lost 20kg Easy As. I didnt feel deprived in any way nor hungry. i have also tried other diets since after believing the propoganda about atkinseg hi fat. no veg blah blah. the problem is everyone looks at the first 2weeks induction and thinks thats the whole diet. if everyone read the book and followed the diet according to Dr Atkins Rules...they would see how great the diet..lifestyle is and how wonderfully it works. last year i tried Tony ferguson which cost a lot and i gained weight, and No i didnt have my hand in the cookie jar. I am on it now again. started last week and already lost 2kg. I am not tired in fact i feel much more full of energy, however i do have yukky breath but i think i can live with that as i really need to get my weight down so its a very small price to pay for long term health, for all you Skeptics READ THE WHOLE BOOK.... yours truly Atkins diet lover
Carbs DO NOT give you diabetes - that's an irresponsible statement straight away. The reason the Atkins diet fails is because carbs are "fuel" and nowhere in the diet was there a prescription for exercise. No diet will work without exercise, and no-one can exercise comfortably without complex carbohydrates in their diet. If you want to lose weight, burn more kilojoules than you consume - not rocket science and not complicated. And plan your weight loss over a longer time period - losing a lot of weight quickly is not healthy, is usually all fluid, and invariably gets put back on just as quickly as it disappears.
at Sally, Perth Carbs = diabetes pretty much about sums up the extent of the level of weird, misplaced anxiety around carbs. Carbs = diabetes makes about as much sense as saying breathing will cause your cells to rust leading to death. Which is ultimately true in a way, but for very obvious reasons we don't "reduce" our oxygen levels or stop breathing to avoid these "side effects"! Carbs are an excellent source of energy for humans and our digestive systems are evolved to process carbs effectively and efficiently. I'd much rather have a filling meal rich in complex carbs than eat a big slab of steak which is going to leave me feeling sluggish and bloated and give me foul breath for the next 12 hours besides as well as being the quickest way to pile on the fat.
From the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine..."Then, on Tuesday, February 10, 2004, Mrs. Atkins released a statement clarifying details about her husband’s health. She confirmed that, in fact, he did have coronary artery disease. In particular, she said that Dr. Atkins “did have some progression of his coronary artery disease in the last three years of his life including some new blockage of a secondary artery that was remedied during this admission….” Artery blockages of this type are typically caused by high-fat, high-cholesterol diets, smoking, and other lifestyle factors." This means that at less than 70 years of age Atkins had these heart problems. You won't find many non-smoking vegetarians or vegans who die this way


Image: Getty ImagesDepressed people act differently online Image: Getty ImagesButter and red meat may increase Alzheimer's risk Image: Getty ImagesSnoring increases cancer risk: study Image: Getty ImagesPlaying video game helps stroke victims recover
advertisement

EXPERTS CORNER

Why don't I lubricate naturally? Our answer SEX EXPERT Desiree Spierings What is the best way stop sugars cravings?Our answer DIET AND NUTRITION EXPERT Lisa Guy